Home / Gordon Ryan / Guard retention / They Shall Not Pass Review
Gordon Ryan’s They Shall Not Pass: Is It Worth It?
Buy it if you’re tired of getting passed and want an answer to every way people pass you. Skip it if you want quick fixes: it’s a long course.
See today’s price on BJJ Fanatics →
Gordon Ryan’s They Shall Not Pass is a whole course on not getting passed, built on one idea: almost every pass has to pin your head and shoulders first, so keep them free. 12 loops of the details first, then the question most buyers ask: this or Danaher’s Unpassable Guard.
The short answer in full
This is the most complete course on not getting passed that I have watched. Gordon starts from the passer’s side: to pass a good guard you need to control the head and shoulders, and the only pass that doesn’t is north-south. So the bottom player’s two jobs are inside position and a free head. Then he goes through every way of passing he names, each with its own goals: loose passing against a seated guard, leg entanglements as retention (a whole volume), split squat and straight hamstring, toreando and flanks, four chapters of north-south, stack passing, body locks and half guard. The answer is rarely a single frame; it is a counter, because “I’m not just retaining, I’m countering”.
What it costs: time. It runs 11 h 48, of which 10 h 09 is studio teaching, and it is lecture-paced. There are no solo movement drills, no knee shield method and no shoulder roll recovery (he argues against it). At $349 list that is a lot; with the house code tested on October 28 it was $146.58, which is $13 per hour of teaching, the cheapest Gordon course per hour I have timed.
Jump to a section
12 details that are worth the money
From early to late in her pass: first she steps in close or steps around your legs (1 to 5), then she ties you up or stacks you (6 to 9), then she is almost past and on top of you (10 to 12).
Arms inside hers before she lands
As she drops in to pass, get inside her biceps first and then inside her shoulders, so her chest never reaches your head.
Vol 1 · 38:42Too close to pommel? Drag yourself back
When she steps in too close to pommel your feet back inside, put both hands and both feet down and drag yourself back out of range.
Vol 1 · 1:25:52She is past the legs: spin back in front
When she forward-steps past your shoulder line, keep hold of her leg and spin on your back until your legs are in front of her again, before she reaches your head.
Vol 2 · 28:18Back step: steer her over, square up again
When she back-steps around your legs on a scoop grip, put your elbow inside her leg and steer her further than she wanted, then square back up in front of her.
Vol 3 · 33:09Her pass attempt: the high leg goes to her centre line
As she steps in to pass, bring your outside leg high over to her centre line, knee inside her arm, and she is back in front of you.
Vol 4 · 41:44Head and arm locked: get your head underneath
When she folds over you with her arms locked round your head and arm, take your hand up and get your head underneath: now she has no control of your head and shoulders.
Vol 4 · 1:00:46Stacked by the ankles: hips up, a leg back inside
When she grabs both ankles to stack you, drive your heels down and your hips up and pommel a leg back inside.
Vol 5 · 11:03Stacked: grip her wrist, straighten the leg, slide out
When she wraps your legs in the stack, grip her wrist and wait: straighten the leg and slide your hips down until her grip is below your knees.
Vol 5 · 18:43Double overs: fall back and lift her over your head
Against a double-overs body lock with both arms trapped, scoot your butt to your heels and lift her over your head so she has to let go to post.
Vol 5 · 1:08:26Knee down: foot over foot, outside her knee
When she flattens your half guard with her knee on the mat, step your top foot over your bottom foot directly outside her knee: that is the knee lever's lock.
Vol 6 · 1:00:12Crossface: knees in, bump her forward
When she pins your head with the crossface, fold your knees in and bump her slightly forward over your shoulder, so your head can come out from under it.
Vol 6 · 1:24:53Under/over: move her head to your near side
Against the under/over pass, put a forearm on her forehead and move her head off the far side of your chest: once it is on your near side, the pass is gone.
Vol 6 · 1:52:44How many of these details do you do?
Count the ones you do in every roll, not just in drilling. If three or more are new to you, this course will change how often you get passed.
House code EXTRAXX58, tested at checkout on October 28, 2026: $146.58 instead of $349.
- No-gi
- 8 volumes, 11 h 48 min
- 25 min of rolls + 1 h 11 of commentary
- No solo drills
- Released April 2021
They Shall Not Pass vs Danaher’s Unpassable Guard
Same method, different answers. Gordon credits Danaher for the goal-first way of teaching retention; once the passer is close, Danaher concedes and recovers late, Gordon fights early and counters.
- 6 Different answer
- 7 Same goal, other frame
- 2 Same detail
- 1 They disagree
- 4 Not in TSNP
North-south
Same position, and neither pushes on the passer’s body. Danaher frames her elbows; Gordon keeps his elbows above his knees, so she drops onto his elbows and knees instead of his chest. Why north-south gets its own chapters: it is the one pass that does not need to pin your head and shoulders first.
The locked body lock
Both move the head off centre once the lock is on. Danaher uses it to get out, a late defence; Gordon uses it to sweep, straight away. None of Danaher’s three safety positions (knee shield, closed guard, omoplata) appears in Gordon’s body lock volume.
Double underhooks in half guard
Both from half guard. Danaher gives up the upper body and keeps the legs tangled; Gordon pulls his elbows down and lifts her over his shoulder until she has to let go with a hand, and his elbow is back inside. Both are honest about the late stage: Gordon says strong double unders or under/overhooks pass you “100% of the time” (Volume 6).
The shoulder roll
“I’m a big advocate of just getting your guard passed if you feel like you’re getting beat and not giving your back up.” Gordon, Volume 1
The one real disagreement. Once he is passed, Danaher turns to turtle and rolls back to guard; Gordon would rather stay passed and escape the pin a few seconds later than turn his back.
All 20 of Danaher’s details, one line each
| Danaher’s detail | Call | What Gordon does |
|---|---|---|
| Knee outside the ankle | Not in TSNP | No knee-prop base detail anywhere in TSNP (no solo movement block at all). |
| The push test | Not in TSNP | No push test or base test. |
| Foot on top of his hand | Same goal, other frame | Danaher beats the hand before it lands (foot over the wrist); Gordon strips the grip after it lands. |
| Two-on-one, thumbs up | Same goal, other frame | Same grip, narrower job: Gordon uses it against the body lock only. |
| Thumb in the elbow, sole on the shoulder | Same goal, other frame | Danaher: sole on the shoulder. Gordon: knee inside the arm at her centre line. |
| Knee prop, hand under the armpit, roll through | They disagree | Clearest disagreement: Danaher teaches the outside shoulder roll as a late recovery; Gordon would rather give up the pass than expose his back, and escapes the pin later. |
| Switch hands, his arm past your head | Same goal, other frame | Both answer the reach for the head with a post; Gordon posts and redirects, Danaher switches hands on the arm. |
| Frame his elbows, not his body | Same goal, other frame | Same position. Danaher posts on her elbows (not her torso); Gordon builds a knee-elbow wall and keeps the elbows above the knees. Both refuse to push the torso. |
| Push the chin, shrimp the other way | Different answer | Both move the head off centre once the lock is on. Danaher pushes the chin and shrimps away (late defence); Gordon uses the off-centre head to sweep (immediate off-balance). |
| Shimmy the lock down to your legs | Different answer | Danaher slides the lock down to the legs; Gordon shifts forward under it. |
| Legs from his shoulders to his biceps | Same goal, other frame | Same heavy-legs logic (make her carry the weight), other grips: V-grips and the toreando, not double scoops. |
| Toes down, knee in front of his hip | Same detail | Same detail, different cue: Danaher says toes down, Gordon says knee below the foot. |
| Feet stacked, shield tense | Not in TSNP | No knee-shield method in TSNP. |
| Toes crossed, post, don't hug | Same detail | Same lock and the same post-not-hug idea; Gordon adds 'not a bridge' and uses it only with her knee down. |
| Knee points against his pass | Same goal, other frame | Both keep the hooking knee pointed at her; Gordon adds the Achilles wedge during the switch. |
| Pinch the hip, stand on the calf | Different answer | Danaher fixes the legs (pinch the hip, foot on the calf); Gordon wins the upper body first. |
| Temple into his armpit | Different answer | Same end state (head out from under the crossface); Gordon uses momentum, Danaher thumbs in the armpit and a kip. Note for 14222: TSNP has no chapter titled after sit-outs, but the footage handles the sit-through crossface live. |
| Placido wrestles, the half guard holds | Different answer | Danaher concedes the upper body and keeps the half guard; Gordon fights the elbows back inside early. Both are honest about the late stage (Danaher's 'nine times out of ten', Gordon's '100% of the time'). |
| Danaher plays guard vs the body lock | Not in TSNP | Different proof format, not a different answer. |
| Knee shield, closed guard, omoplata at speed | Different answer | Danaher's safety positions are knee shield, closed guard and omoplata; Gordon stays seated, makes angle and off-balances. None of Danaher's three appears. |
| Has it? | They Shall Not Pass | Unpassable Guard |
|---|---|---|
| A seated guard block | Yes | No |
| Leg entanglements as retention | Yes | No |
| Solo movement drills | No | Yes |
| A knee shield method | No | Yes |
| The shoulder roll as a recovery | No | Yes |
| Live rolls with commentary | Yes | No |
Both runtimes timed from the files. Lachlan’s anthology bundle is not timed here: $247 on the October 28 listing ($297 before the sale). The yes/no rows come from mapping 20 of Danaher’s details onto Gordon’s footage.
Three retention courses, one call each:
They Shall Not Pass
Gordon, 2021: seated, legs, half guard, stack and body locks, with 25 min of rolls and an hour of commentary. $146.58 with the code.
The Fastest Way: Unpassable Guard
Danaher, 2024: 5 h 13, solo movements, the knee shield and late recoveries, $197 list.
Guard Retention Anthology
Lachlan Giles and Ariel Tabak, 2020: Reddit’s default answer, $247 for the bundle. Not timed here.
Where they overlap, and what each has that the other doesn’t
Gordon says it in the first minutes of Volume 1: “when John teaches us retention, again, he doesn’t show every different position”. Both courses give you goals per position instead of a list of reactions, and Gordon borrows Danaher’s words for the plow and the half guard paradox. They Shall Not Pass came out in 2021, Unpassable Guard in 2024.
Only in They Shall Not Pass: a seated guard block against loose passing, a whole volume on leg entanglements as retention, split squat and straight hamstring, stack passing, under/over defence, and the rolls with an hour of commentary. Only in Unpassable Guard: 12 solo movements and the knee prop base, the knee shield, double scoops as their own block and the late recoveries by name (shoulder roll, knee prop, elbow prop). Our Unpassable Guard review has the Danaher side in loops.
Does it work? The rolls and his own Worlds match
The teaching volumes are studio demos, but Volume 7 is live rolls with no talking, Volume 8 is Gordon explaining every one, and in Volume 2 he points you to a match of his own on YouTube.
Proof ledger1 of his own matches he namesIBJJF No-Gi Worlds 2018 vs Yuri Simoes25 min of live rollstraining footage, Vol 71 h 11 of Gordon explaining themVol 8Partly cooperative rollshis words, Vol 8
Competition Gordon Ryan vs Yuri Simoes, No-Gi Worlds 2018The IBJJF’s upload of the ultra-heavy semifinal (13 min). Gordon in Volume 2, on the outside ashi with her knee on the floor: “he actually body locks me and he tries to pass me from here and I recover”.What the rolls and the commentary show, and what they don’t
Volume 7 is 25 minutes of rolls at Bernardo Faria’s academy, five rounds of about five minutes with several training partners, with no talking. Volume 8 plays them again with Gordon talking over them for 1 h 11: which passing style the partner chose, which goal he was working on, and where the material from the studio volumes shows up. In the roll above he names the moment himself: “you can see it so clearly here”.
What it is not: competition footage. The rolls are training, and partly cooperative by his own words: “I’m just letting him camp past the J spot just because I want him to try to pass me”. Volume 8 is a screen recording of the same rolls, so the figures are small. The Worlds match is the IBJJF’s, not part of the course.
Who should buy it
Find yourself in a bucket. One reason each; the pros and cons follow below.
- Gets passed a lotEvery passing style in one place, each with a goal: keep inside position, keep the head free.
- No-gi competitorAnswers for when the passer is already close, plus rolls where he explains every decision.
- Leg entanglement playerA whole volume on using ashi positions as retention; Danaher’s Unpassable Guard has none.
- Owns Unpassable GuardSeated, legs and stack passing are new; the goals and north-south overlap.
- Gi playerThe ideas carry over, but no grips on the pants or sleeves are taught.
- Owns his seated guard setVolume 1 repeats some of it: his own words, “a lot of this we saw”.
- White belt11 h 48 of lecture-style teaching: a white belt buyer called it “quite overwhelming”.
- Wants a short planDanaher’s Unpassable Guard does the basics in 5 h 13 for $197.
What BJJ Reddit says about They Shall Not Pass
Lachlan Giles “has a better guard and is a better teacher”, u/novaskar (August 2026), the top answer in a thread on retention courses. The Giles/Tabak anthology is the default recommendation in most threads.
On length: worth the money, but so in depth he had to stop and could not watch it in one sitting, u/Historical_Mess_5262 (February 2022).
The split is guard type, not quality: “Gordon or Danaher’s if you play inside guards, Lachlan’s if you play outside guards”, u/WoeToTheUsurper2.
An owner of both called Lachlan’s the superior set but voted Gordon’s, because Lachlan’s was too advanced for him (u/Creonte_Wilder, 2022). Another found the north-south retention “the best method I’ve found so far” (u/alienvsvampire).
My answer: the split matches the footage. Gordon plays guards where the passer is already close (seated, legs, half guard, against body locks) and lets her get much closer than an outside guard player would. The length complaint is fair: 11 h 48 measured, so watch it a volume at a time, and if you want the short version, Danaher’s is 5 h 13. Buyers on BJJ Fanatics say the same from the other side: “my guard has been passed way less” (Dave C., 2023).
Worth it? The pros and cons
- One idea that explains every chapter: passes need the head and shoulders, except north-south
- Every passing style he names, each with goals: loose, legs, split squat, toreando, flanks, stack, body lock, half guard
- A whole volume on leg entanglements as retention, which Danaher’s Unpassable Guard does not have
- Counters, not only recoveries: the sumi gaeshi off the body lock, lifting her over your head off double overs
- 25 min of live rolls plus 1 h 11 of Gordon explaining them
- $13 per teaching hour with the code: the cheapest Gordon course I have timed
- 11 h 48, lecture-paced: buyers and Reddit both call it a lot to watch
- No solo movement drills and no knee shield method
- No shoulder roll: he argues for getting passed instead, so you need pin escapes
- Volume 1 repeats parts of his seated guard course, by his own words
- $349 list, $152 more than Danaher’s Unpassable Guard
- Volume 8 is a screen recording, and the jokes at his partner’s expense get old
Buy it if, skip it if: the full version
You play no-gi from seated, leg entanglements or half guard and keep getting flattened, flanked or body locked. Or you own Danaher’s Unpassable Guard and want the counters and the passing styles it doesn’t cover. You need a training partner for every chapter.
You want a short plan (Danaher’s is 5 h 13), you play outside guards first (Lachlan Giles and Ariel Tabak’s Guard Retention Anthology), you own his seated open guard set and mainly want more of that, or you train mostly in the gi.
Mat test plan: what I’ll test in live rolling before the score update
This is a first-watch review: the score comes from watching and timing all eight volumes and analyzing every technique shown. What I’ll test before the update:
- Elbows over knees against a north-south pass
- Batting the head over off a locked body lock instead of waiting under it
- Lifting her over my head off a double overs body lock
- Getting passed on purpose instead of the shoulder roll, then escaping the pin
The ranking in our best guard retention instructionals follows after that test.
Ten hours of goals and counters. $146.58 with EXTRAXX58 (tested Oct 28)
What’s inside: one idea, eight volumes
Every way of passing he names, from loose to tight, then the rolls. Tap a volume for what’s in it.
- 1The one chinkhead and shoulders, inside position
- 2Seated vs loosestance, distance, inside foot
- 3Leg entanglementsashi as retention, five groups
- 4Split squatscoop grips, the back step
- 5Flanks + north-southhigh legs, framing, elbows over knees
- 6Tight passingstack, body lock, half guard
Why the order matters more than the moves
“If you want to pass a high-level guard player, you pass them to North-South. Why? Because you don’t have to control the head and shoulders” is the idea in Volume 1 that the rest hangs on. Every other pass needs your head and shoulders pinned, so the bottom player wins by keeping inside position and a free head, and north-south gets its own answer: elbows above the knees.
The other thread is countering. Each passing style comes with its goals for the passer and for you, and the answer is usually an attack: strip the grip and scoop a leg, sweep off the body lock, make the back step bigger than she wanted.
Vol 1 · 1:43:54Goals, inside position, seated guardthe one chink in passing, concave shoulders, hiding the jaw, seated vs loose passing
Top and bottom players’ goals in loose and tight passing, the one chink in the armour (north-south), the battle for inside position, concave shoulders, hiding the jaw from a crossface (the chapter BJJ Fanatics put on YouTube), then seated guard against loose passing: stances, distance, the grip fight, maintaining and recovering the inside foot, recovering when she flanks, and a supine overview.
Vol 2 · 1:33:09Leg entanglements vs loose passingfive ashi groups, forward and back steps, outside ashi, double unders
The five groups of leg entanglements as retention, recovering when she forward-steps or back-steps, outside ashi with the inside position, reclaiming the Achilles grip, recovering from a top head and arm, 11 minutes on double underhooks and a chapter on kata gatame. This is where he points to his Worlds match with Yuri Simoes.
Vol 3 · 1:16:14Split squat and straight hamstringcollar tie, knee cut, forced half guard, scoop grips, top pommel
Against the split squat: clearing a collar tie, preventing the knee cut and the forced half guard, scoop grips and the back step (one of the details above), the spun leg, the underhook. Against the straight hamstring with the inside foot: reclaiming the inside foot against low hips and countering a top pommel against high hips.
Vol 4 · 1:42:03Toreando, flanks, north-souththree types of framing, scissor and side guard, high legs, leg drag, four north-south chapters
The bridge between loose and tight passing, three types of framing, scissor guard and side guard, pommeling the legs to stop a flank, high legs against the toreando (the hero loop), forehand, forearm and backhand framing, knee on belly, the leg drag, then four chapters on recovering from north-south.
Vol 5 · 1:53:14Stack passing and body locksthe plow, V grips, locked hands, shin pins, forward shifting
Stack passing front and rear facing (“what John calls a plow”): avoiding the stack, clearing V grips, locked hands round your legs, outside and inside shin pins. Then body locks: stopping the lock, off-balancing straight after it, 17 minutes of forward shifting (the sumi gaeshi and the double overs lift), a knee block, a forced cross shin, butterfly half and recovering after a “pass”.
Vol 6 · 2:02:34Half guard and under/overbutterfly hooks vs every top grip, knee up or down, the knee lever, under/over defence
The longest volume. Half guard against every top grip he names (head and arm, underhook and head wedge, over-under, double unders, crossface, near side underhook), the knee up or knee down dilemma, the knee lever series, late escapes, 22 minutes on the reverse underhook, 18 minutes of under/over defence and a 13-minute outro.
Vol 7 · 25:40Live rollsfive rounds of about five minutes, no talking
Training rolls with several partners at Bernardo Faria’s academy, each starting from a pass attempt. Training footage, not competition.
Vol 8 · 1:11:02Gordon commenting on the rollsthe same rolls again, with his decisions explained
The Volume 7 rolls replayed with Gordon talking over them: which passing style, which goal, why he switched. A screen recording, so the picture is small. Watch it after the teaching volumes; it is the best review of the system in the set.
They Shall Not Pass in numbers
Timed from the files: every volume, every chapter. Teaching time is the runtime minus live rolls, promo and intro.
Third cheapest of the 17 instructionals I have timed the same way. Teaching = runtime minus live rolls, promo and intro; Gordon’s 1 h 11 of commentary over the rolls counts as teaching. Without it, studio teaching alone is 10 h 09: $14 per hour with the code.
- 10 h 09 Studio teaching (Vols 1-6)
- 1 h 11 Gordon commenting on the rolls (Vol 8)
- 25 min Live rolls (Vol 7)
About 3 minutes are BJJ Fanatics intro cards. The rolls are training footage at a gym, not competition, and partly cooperative by Gordon’s own words.
Every volume’s length, and the table
| Vol | Topic | Length | Talking |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goals, inside position, seated guard | 1:43:54 | 96% |
| 2 | Leg entanglements vs loose passing | 1:33:09 | 96% |
| 3 | Split squat and straight hamstring | 1:16:14 | 95% |
| 4 | Toreando, flanks, north-south | 1:42:03 | 95% |
| 5 | Stack passing and body locks | 1:53:14 | 96% |
| 6 | Half guard and under/over | 2:02:34 | 96% |
| 7 | Live rolls | 25:40 | 0% |
| 8 | Commentary on the rolls | 1:11:02 | 73% |
| Total | 108 chapters | 11:47:53 | 90% |
Our older review said 11 h 3 min. The measured total is 11:47:53, of which 10:09:10 is studio teaching.
Only 4 min 21 is free on YouTube word for word: BJJ Fanatics posted the hiding-your-jaw chapter from Volume 1. Watch it before you buy: if his pace works for you there, it works for the set.
How I checked the free material
I compared the free BJJ Fanatics upload and Bernardo Faria’s two promo videos with the course audio. Only that chapter is the same recording; Bernardo’s videos teach the same ideas in a separate session (3-4% of the words match).
Compare to
- The Fastest Way: Unpassable GuardJohn Danaher · $197: the short, solo-drill-first course with the knee shield and the late recoveries. See it on BJJ Fanatics or read our review.
- Guard Retention AnthologyLachlan Giles + Ariel Tabak · $247 bundle: Reddit’s default answer, the pick for outside guards. Our review.
- Systematically Attacking From Open Guard: SeatedGordon Ryan · $349: the seated guard set that Volume 1 partly repeats. Our review.
- Guard Retention Made EasyFiras Zahabi: a lighter, concept-first option. Our review.
More options in our best guard retention instructionals and every Gordon Ryan instructional ranked.
Get the next review like this one
New reviews in this format land in your inbox, with the timestamps and loops. You also get the free BJJMore email course and the instructional-platform discounts I use myself (worth $46).
FAQ
Is They Shall Not Pass worth it?
Not at $349: nobody needs to pay list. With the house code tested on October 28, 2026 it was $146.58, which is $13 per hour of teaching. At that price it is worth it if you keep getting passed: flattened, flanked or body locked. If you want a short plan, buy Danaher’s Unpassable Guard.
They Shall Not Pass or Lachlan Giles’s Guard Retention Anthology?
It depends on your guard. Gordon’s is for guards where the passer is already close: seated, leg entanglements, half guard, and what to do against body locks. Reddit’s usual advice is Lachlan’s anthology for outside guards; I have not timed Lachlan’s here, and the bundle was $247 on October 28.
They Shall Not Pass or Danaher’s Unpassable Guard?
Danaher’s if you want a short plan with solo drills, the knee shield and late recoveries: 5 h 13, $197 list. Gordon’s if you want every passing style with its own counters, including leg entanglements, stack passing and body locks: 11 h 48. They share the goal-first method, and they disagree on the shoulder roll.
How long is it?
11 hours 48 minutes over eight volumes and 108 chapters: 10 h 09 of studio teaching in Volumes 1 to 6, 25 minutes of live rolls in Volume 7 and 1 h 11 of Gordon commenting on those rolls in Volume 8.
Is it gi or no-gi?
No-gi. The ideas (inside position, a free head, the goals per pass) carry over to the gi, but no gi grips are taught.
Is it good for beginners?
For a motivated blue belt, yes; as a first course for a white belt, it is a lot. A white belt buyer on BJJ Fanatics called it “quite overwhelming at times”. Watch one volume at a time and drill it with a partner.
Does it overlap with his seated guard instructional?
Partly, in Volume 1. Gordon says so himself: “a lot of this we saw in the seated guard instructional”. Volumes 2 to 6 (legs, split squat, flanks, stack, body locks, half guard) are not in that set.
Is there a discount code?
On October 28, 2026 the house code EXTRAXX58 took 58% off at checkout: $146.58 instead of $349. BJJ Fanatics rotates these codes and deals, so check the price on the day you buy.
What’s free on YouTube?
One chapter word for word: BJJ Fanatics posted the hiding-your-jaw-from-a-crossface chapter from Volume 1 (4 min 21). Bernardo Faria’s promo videos teach the same ideas in a separate recording.
Stop getting passed
If your guard gets flattened, flanked or body locked, this is the most complete answer I have watched: ten hours of goals and counters, then the rolls and his commentary. Don’t pay list for it.
House code EXTRAXX58, tested at checkout on October 28, 2026: 58% off, $146.58 instead of $349.

01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12