A data-backed, community-tested ranking of BJJ Fanatics instructionals that fit ecological, constraints-led training: what to buy now, what to wait on, and who each set helps most.
How to Defend Against Everyone
Build resilient defense with simple postures and heuristics that drop straight into your sparring.
Guard Retention Anthology: Through the Legs & Close Range
Make your guard stubborn with distance layers, pummeling, and recoveries you can pressure-test in games.
The Turtle & Panda
Adopt Turtle and Panda to survive, move, and re-enter offense from bad positions.
📋 Jump to a review (Click to expand)
🥋 #1 How to Defend Against Everyone by Chris Paines
Instructor: Chris Paines
Style: Conceptual, System Based
Best for: All Levels
Format: Both
Runtime: 2 hours and 9 minutes
Volumes: 5
Biggest takeaway: Defense runs on posture and checks.
Techniques: Defensive Postures, Turtle, Frames, Guard Retention, Armbar Defense, Kimura Defense, Heel Hook Defense
- Pin Escapes & Turtle Escapes: Go Further Faster – Broader escape fundamentals if you want more traditional structure.
- The Turtle & Panda – Dial-in late-stage survival with posture-led defense.
- Guard Retention Anthology: Through the Legs & Close Range – Pair defense with world-class retention layers and drills.
This is a concept-first defense system that maps directly to ecological training. You learn posture, frames, and decision shortcuts for common submissions and pressure scenarios. It won’t hand you flashy attacks, but it will stop the bleeding and give you reliable exits to re-guard or come up.
✅ Pros
- Heuristics make live decision-making easier under stress.
- Posture-based defense integrates cleanly with constraints-led games.
- Covers high-risk submissions across gi and no-gi contexts.
⚠️ Cons
- Light on immediate offense; you must connect attacks yourself.
- Dense lecture segments can overwhelm first viewing.
- Minimal drilling templates included; you must design games.
💡 I find the simple posture checks make troubleshooting during rounds far less chaotic. Recommendation: Buy it now.
🥋 #2 Guard Retention Anthology: Through the Legs & Close Range by Lachlan Giles & Ariel Tabak
Instructor: Lachlan Giles & Ariel Tabak
Style: System Based, Conceptual
Best for: Intermediate
Format: Both
Volumes: 8
Biggest takeaway: Distance layers decide retention.
Techniques: Guard Retention, Leg Pummeling, Knee Shield Defense, Headquarters Defense, Late Stage Recovery, Distance Management
- Guard Retention Anthology: Around & Under – Complements this set with over/around passing counters.
- Pin Escapes & Turtle Escapes: Go Further Faster – If you need core escape principles first.
A structured, modern approach to keeping your guard against common passes. You get distance frameworks, counters, and ways to train them. Expect some inversion and mobility work; beginners may want an escape primer first.
✅ Pros
- Clear distance framework with actionable counters and recoveries.
- Shows how to train retention inside rounds, not just drill it.
- Excellent pacing and editing; easy to rewatch by topic.
⚠️ Cons
- Some sequences need mobility or light inversion.
- Not ideal as your very first fundamentals resource.
- Overlap with subscription content for some students.
💡 I like how the set teaches where to start rounds and what distances to protect. Recommendation: Wait for daily deal.
🥋 #3 The Turtle & Panda by Priit Mihkelson
Instructor: Priit Mihkelson
Style: Conceptual, System Based
Best for: All Levels
Format: Both
Runtime: 2 hours and 15 minutes
Biggest takeaway: Shapes beat panic under pressure.
Techniques: Turtle, Panda, Frames, Stand Ups, Re Guarding, Pressure Management
- How to Defeat the Mount and Improve Your Game – Another posture-led survival set for bad spots.
- Protecting & Generating Dynamic Offense from Turtle – Adds offense pathways from the same shapes.
Priit’s signature defensive shapes are built for pressure. You learn how to protect vital levers, stall control, and create motion for stand-ups or guard recovery. Offense is minimal here; combine it with a separate attacking plan.
✅ Pros
- Late-stage structure that stops panic and buys time.
- Pairs perfectly with constraint games starting in Turtle/Panda.
- Clear lever-denial logic that transfers across positions.
⚠️ Cons
- Sparse attack chains; you must add offense elsewhere.
- Polarizing; results vary by body type and ruleset.
- Some positions need coaching to avoid passivity.
💡 I see the biggest gains when classes start in Turtle and rotate constraints for exits. Recommendation: Wait for daily deal.
🥋 #4 Turning Defensive Cycles Into Offensive Cycles by Chris Paines
Instructor: Chris Paines
Style: Conceptual, System Based
Best for: All Levels
Format: Both
Runtime: 2 hours and 20 minutes
Biggest takeaway: Escapes must become scores.
Techniques: Stand Ups, Reversals, Elbow Frame, Hip Heist, Grip Denial, Turtle To Attack, Guard Recovery To Sweep
- How to Defend Against Everyone – Build the defensive base first if you are new.
- Unstoppable Standups – Emphasizes stand-ups that pair with defensive exits.
You learn to bridge defense to points: stand-ups, reversals, and quick attacks. The ideas fit constraints-led rounds that start in disadvantage. If you want a traditional move list, this will feel lecture-forward.
✅ Pros
- Provides scoring goals for defense-focused players.
- Great prompts for designing constraint games that reward offense.
- Transfers across gi and no-gi easily.
⚠️ Cons
- Concept-heavy delivery may not suit all learners.
- Some content overlaps with free talks and clips.
- No single-position deep dive; it is system glue.
💡 I like using its scoring rules in rounds to force immediate offense post-escape. Recommendation: Wait for daily deal.
🥋 #5 Pin Escapes & Turtle Escapes: BJJ Fundamentals – Go Further Faster by John Danaher
Instructor: John Danaher
Style: Conceptual, Technique Collection
Best for: All Levels
Format: Both
Runtime: 11 hours and 57 minutes
Biggest takeaway: Escape mechanics matter most early.
Techniques: Pin Escapes, Turtle Escapes, Bridge And Roll, Hip Escape, Frames, Shoulder Line
- How to Defend Against Everyone – Faster ecological integration if you want posture-led defense.
- The Turtle & Panda – Late-stage shapes that pair with games.
A detailed survey of pin and turtle escapes. You learn structural concepts and stepwise mechanics that many competitors still use. It is not games-focused, so you must create your own practice design.
✅ Pros
- Very clear baseline mechanics for common bad positions.
- Pairs well with ecological constraints once you grasp structure.
- Timeless fundamentals for any ruleset.
⚠️ Cons
- Pacing is slow and verbose for some learners.
- Not designed around constraints-led games.
- High price relative to niche needs.
💡 I use it as a reference when students need structure before we design games. Recommendation: Skip.
What makes an instructional ecological?
It helps you design games, not just memorize moves. Look for posture and decision heuristics, distance frameworks, and constraints suggestions. Trailers or product pages that mention positional sparring, practice design, stand-ups after escapes, or late-stage recoveries typically fit. If an instructional is move-dense with little guidance on how to train, use it as a reference and build your own games around the core ideas.
How to run constraint-led rounds with these sets
Pick a shape (e.g., Turtle, leg pummeling distance). Define a score: stand-up, sweep, or back exposure. Limit grips or pathways. Start in disadvantage, switch roles on score or escape, and log one focus per week. Two 6–8 minute blocks per class are enough to build retention and exits while leaving time for normal sparring.
Beginner vs. intermediate picks
Newer students: start with Paines’ How to Defend Against Everyone for posture and checks. Pair it with short Turtle or Panda games. Intermediates: add Guard Retention Anthology to protect distance and build leg pummeling. When your escapes work, use Turning Defensive Cycles to convert success into points.
💙 Was this article helpful?
Share it with your training partners!
